| New York Jets Most Valuable Player |
| Year |
Winner |
| 2005 |
Jonathan Vilma, LB |
| 2004 |
Curtis Martin, RB |
| 2003 |
Santana Moss, WR |
| 2002 |
Chad Pennington, QB |
| 2001 |
Curtis Martin, RB |
| 2000 |
Curtis Martin, RB |
| 1999 |
Curtis Martin, RB |
| 1998 |
Vinny Testaverde, QB |
| 1997 |
Mo Lewis, LB |
| 1996 |
Adrian Murrell, RB |
| 1995 |
Marvin Jones, LB |
| 1994 |
Mo Lewis, LB |
| 1993 |
Johnny Johnson, RB |
| 1992 |
Brian Washington, SS |
| 1991 |
Chris Burkett, WR |
| 1990 |
Pat Leahy, K |
| 1989 |
JoJo Townsell, WR-KR |
| 1988 |
Al Toon, WR |
| 1987 |
Al Toon, WR |
| 1986 |
Al Toon, WR |
| 1985 |
Ken O'Brien, QB |
| 1984 |
Freeman McNeil, RB |
| 1983 |
Lance Mehl, LB |
| 1982 |
Freeman McNeil, RB |
| 1981 |
Richard Todd, QB |
| 1980 |
Bruce Harper, RB-KR |
| 1979 |
Marvin Powell, OT |
| 1978 |
Wesley Walker, WR |
| 1977 |
Randy Rasmussen, OG |
| 1976 |
Clark Gaines, FB |
| 1975 |
John Riggins, FB |
| 1974 |
Joe Namath, QB |
| 1973 |
Emerson Boozer, FB |
| 1972 |
John Riggins, FB |
| 1971 |
Larry Grantham, LB |
| 1970 |
John Elliott, DT |
| 1969 |
Joe Namath, QB |
| 1968 |
Joe Namath, QB |
| 1967 |
Don Maynard, WR |
| 1966 |
George Sauer, WR |
| 1965 |
Matt Snell, FB |
| 1964 |
Dainard Paulson, S |
| 1963 |
Bake Turner, WR |
| 1962 |
Dick Christy, RB |
| 1961 |
Bill Mathis, RB |
