Would you do this??

No, because they're not even asking for a first rounder for him. I'd offer the late 2nd or the 3rd though. Doubtful they trade him in the division anyway.

 

No. Why do you ask? I don't get why anyone would want him that much.

 

No way!!! The Bills will be lucky to get a 2nd round pick

 

no but the bills wont deal him to us

 

Absolutely not. They're not asking for a 1st (they wouldn't get one even if they were). He's an injury risk. He's got a lot of mileage on him. And his only big games last year were against the Jets. As a result, as Jets fans, we have a distorted view of how good he is.

 

This is just what I'm talking about. He is always a beast AGAINST US.

 

But a lot of starting time and carries. Going from college up through the pros.

 

Outside of the games against us, McGahee is one of the more unimpressive running backs in the league!

First round you say? I remember when Shawn alexander and edgerrin james weren't even tradeable for 2nd round picks not long ago.

 

He has two good games a year. Other than games against us, he's not a good RB at all. I would never give up a first DAY pick for him, let alone first ROUND.

 

Exactly. Well said.

 

hahahha! You mean the line that everyone on here is SCREAMING to upgrade??? The line with no RT right now???

 

Only if we throw in K. Rhodes and Mangold.

 

And then we get back future MVP JP Losman

 

Our 1st for mcgahee, kick rocks.

 

No way, Mcgahee wont even go for a 1st round. I wouldn't be mad if we got him for a 4th round pick but i dont think we should go for him.

 

Noooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!

 

No way! McGahee is slowing down big time! He only had 2 100 yd games last yr, both against us!