Don Maynard 13 George Sauer 83 Al Toon 88 Wayne Chrebet 80 Wesley Walker 85 Keyshawn Johnson 19 Bake Turner 29 Rich Caster 88 Gee Barkum 83 Laveranues Coles 87 Rob Moore 85 Jerricho Cotchery 89 Santana Moss 83 Kurt Sohn 87 Dedric Ward 89 Bobby Jones 89 Derrick Gaffney 81 Eddie Bell 7 JoJo Townsell 83 Bill Rademacher 23 David Knight 82
Need a poll. Maynard, the Hall of Famer. If Toon hadn't gotten hurt, or Sauer hadn't quit early, they might very well have ended up being the best, but they did, and that's why it's Maynard.
That would be quite a task, and you didn't list them all. There are at least 3 from just last season that aren't on there.
^^ I agree!! I still say Toon was the most talented WR we have ever had. This is where I totally agree with WB. I also personally think Sauer was better than Maynard and was heading for the HOF had he not cut his career short. Toon was also headed for the HOF before injuries cut his career short :sad:
I never got to see Maynard play other than a couple of old highlight plays. Toon is far and away the best one that I can remember.
Don Maynard. He is in the hall of fame for a reason. I was wondering why Johnny Lam Jones was omitted from the list?
Great player, always made clutch catches, had great moves and hands, but not great speed, which was amazing because he always beat the best cornerbacks in the AFL deep...
1960-1964 (Pre-Namath) 1. Art Powell 2. Bake Turner 1965 to 1969 (Golden Era) 1. Maynard 2. Sauer 3. Turner 1970 to 1976 (Dead Zone) 1. Barkum 2. Caster 3. Maynard 3. Bell 4. Knight 1977 to 1980 (Michael's New Era) 1. Walker 2. Gaffney 3. Barkum (TE) 1981 to 1986 (Silver Era) 1. Walker 2. Lam Jones [5 years, 61 games, 138 catches, 2322 yds, 13 TDs] 3. Derrick Gaffney [10 years, 100 games, 156 catches, 2613 yards, 7 TDs] 4. Bobby Jones 1987 to 1989 (Walton's Fall) 1. Toon 2. Walker 3. Sohn 1990 to 1994 [Coslet and Carroll] 1. Moore 2. Toon (only 2 years here) 3. Burkett 4. Mathis 1995 to 1999 [Kotite through Parcells] 1. Chrebet 2. Keyshawn 3. Ward 2000 to 2005 [Groh through Herm; Bronze Era] 1. Coles 2. Chrebet 3. Moss 2006 to Present [Mangenius] 1. Cotchery 2. Coles 3. McCareins [sad but true]
Don Maynard 13 George Sauer 83 Al Toon 88 Wayne Chrebet 80 Wesley Walker 85 Keyshawn Johnson 19 Bake Turner 29 Rich Caster 88 Gee Barkum 83 Laveranues Coles 87 Rob Moore 85 Jerricho Cotchery 89 Santana Moss 83 Johnny Lam Jones 80 Kurt Sohn 87 Dedric Ward 89 Bobby Jones 89 Derrick Gaffney 81 Terrance Mathis 81 Eddie Bell 7 JoJo Townsell 83 Art Monk 81 Mark Smolinski 30 Bill Rademacher 23 Lou Piccone 89 David Knight 82 Curtis Conway 81 Justin McCareins 81 Matthew Hatchette 81 Wallace Wright 15 Brad Hall 16 Chansi Stuckey 83 __________________
Toon is easily the most talented and complete WR we've ever had. I sincerely believe he'd be considered among the all time greats had he not suffered from the concussions and been able to play on some better teams.
I agree with you 100% on this. Al Toon was a great player and it is a shame to see what happened to him.
Don't be silly...I love Chrebet as much as the next guy...but there is no way he is better than Key or Moss. Al Toon is the best I ever did see...and I'm a big fan of Rob Moore.
^ Yeah Rob Moore was friggin' awesome! Could you imagine had Toon stayed healthy having Moore and Toon!
Maynard first. Toon had the better talent than Walker, but Walker made the greater overall contributions.
