O.K. here me out before you kill me, as I stated in a different thread I am picking forth in my league and in listening to these guys in front of me I will have A.P. and Michael Turner. All I am saying is look at the stats Turner had in 2008 he was a freakin beast.....even being hurt last year he had 10 td's
I think you gotta go with Peterson just for the durability issue. Aside from that, Turner doesn't catch the ball nearly as much as AP. Peterson put up 18 TDs last year and had 43 receptions for 436 yards. Compare that to Turner who had 6 catches in 08 and 5 catches in 09. Should Favre not come back, I think AP's work load just increased significantly not to mention there is there no more Chester Taylor.