Not sure. Depends on if they consider him done after the 2005 season or 2006 season since he was on PUP the entire 06 season, I'm not sure. I'd say best bet is 2011. I am definitely making out the trip to see C-Mart.
He played his last game in 2005, I would guess they go by that even if he didn't officially retire until 2006 or so. Not sure though, 35 years as a Jet fan has left me pretty uneducated about Hall of Fame procedures.