Nobody who's watched a Chiefs game in the last two years would seriously advocate for Todd Haley as the OC. Got the most explosive running back in football? Yup, better give Thomas Jones 20 carries a game. Got one of the top 5 deep threats in the game? Sorry Dwayne Bowe, you aren't gritty enough for Todd Haley. Haley parlayed having unbelievable talent in Arizona into a head coaching job, and now he's being exposed as a fraud. Plus, he's notorious for being a tremendous douchebag. Stay far, far away form him.
Too many bad things have to happen before we can even consider Haley as an OC. I'd just as well stay positive and hope for us to play better in all areas.
Callahan turned the Raiders offense into a Top 5 unit as OC. And before anyone points out that Gannon joined the Raiders at the same time, he had never had a 2500 yd passing season prior to joining the Raiders. His lowest total under Callahan was 3430 yards. He also had never thrown more than 16 TDs in a season. His lowest with the Raiders was 24. Callahan is perfectly qualified to run our offense.
I really felt the point you addressed in #2 was a big issue yesterday. I was actually happy with Shotty early in the game. Unfortunately, when Oakland adjusted to the Jets offensive game plan Shotty seemed to not have a plan B. How does that happen?
Haley is a bad idea. If Schotty is replaced, I'd love for The Jets to get Marc Trestman. Trestman is currently a Head Coach in the CFL and is highly regarded as a brilliant offensive mind that works very well wirth QBs. I don't know if Trestman would be interested, but he would be a perfect mentor for Sanchez. Bernie Kosar, Jake Plummer, & Rich Gannon had their best years and huge #s under Trestman.